[一个时代的记忆] 关于HP亲世代CP的一点讨论

今早在XQ看到一张对HP的表白帖,下午回来发现那帖都翻了7页了,爬了几页楼,在这个你永远不是一个人的地方,很多埋在记忆深处的东西渐渐被勾了出来,就想写点什么抒发抒发,也不枉我到现在还死心塌地喜欢着这群人。

HP世界里,我是彻头彻尾的亲世代饭。根据JKR后妈的设定,我曾经梳理过亲世代的人物关系架构,但那篇文不知道被我塞哪里去了只找到一半= =此架构的最终结论是哈利同学就是个杯具是个错误,而排除里德尔这个客观因素,他老爹叉子同学是最可恶的混球。昨天和悦悦讨论亲世代CP问题时有谈到此架构的些许,一时半会儿说不全,但我下定决心一定要抽空把整个架构理出来,就用来给犬狼CPF洗脑= =如果我勤奋点,寒假应该可以弄出来。

至于我,我是鹿犬派的,原因可以讲上一天一夜,但归结起来就是真爱。别跟我说这年头还信真爱可笑不可笑,你们就是做人太狭隘才看不到真爱。在XQ那帖还是发现不少同好的,加之最近发现bo里某篇几百年前的练笔文点击量有点吓人,所以想要重新拾起来(其实是转移视线)。一是继续填坑,二是做个阅文整理,不过最近都找不出时间,还是得等放假静下心来再做。

今天是想贴一篇关于鹿犬CP和犬狼CP的分析,以前经人指路从fiction alley上扒下来的,不过现在上这论坛似乎要翻。本来CP各萌各的,掐CP是最无意义且永无结果的论战,但这帖的分析有些真是戳到我心坎里去,所以放上来借鉴。

摘自(JP/SB V.S. SB/RL)

http://forums.fictionalley.org/park/showthread.php?s=&postid=1040260

BY Regensburg

Summary: Either platonically or romantically, James and Sirius' relationship was far deeper than anything Remus and Sirius ever shared, like, ever.

Assertion 1: James and Sirius' relationship was timeless. Remus and Sirius' relationship? Less so.

Supporting evidence: When James dies, Sirius is obsessed, hurt, and driven somewhat insane. He continues to search for James within James' son, Harry. When Sirius dies, Remus voice cracks for one scene. He shows more pain when Dumbledore dies. He mentions Sirius apprx. once, in a negative way. Sirius doesn't give Remus anything. He gives it all to his James' rich son, Harry.

Assertion 2: James and Sirius' relationship has many side relationships that mimic that of a traditional relationship.

Supporting evidence: They share parents, just as it is common after marriage. More importantly, they share a son. They are Harry's more prominent parents, Lily has purposely been background. She obviously has her own role to play, and will
(and even already has) reveal herself to be more than a surrogate mother, but James and Sirius are Harry's more personal parents, so far. Not like Remus has any kids, but Sirius doesn't mention Remus' parents as any sort of force in his life. Or Remus, for that matter.

Assertion 3: James and Sirius' relationship has been repeatedly contrasted with Sirius and Remus' relationship, as the one that is far more trusting.

Supporting evidence: James, in choosing between Sirius and Albus Dumbledore, who you know you can trust, chose Sirius to be his secret keeper, and insisted on it. Sirius believed Remus was a DE spy. When Sirius had no place to go pre-James dying, he went to James, and trusted him enough that he would find a home there. When he had no place to go post-James dying, he lived in a cave. Even though Lupin had a home and all. He had to be ordered to do anything else.

Assertion 4: James understands Sirius. Remus has no idea what things he is talking about.

Supporting Evidence: Ha, pensieve scene. Sirius is bored. Remus tells him to help him study. If this is him trying to keep Sirius occupied and out of trouble, or if he is really looking for a study partner, it is a pretty pathetic idea, so Sirius naturally shoots him down. James knows what Sirius wants, he understands Sirius' mood.

Assertion 5: James and Sirius were better friends than Remus and Sirius.

Supporting Evidence: Sirius says James was the best friend he ever had. Also, JKR interview strongly suggests that James was one of his most important people. Post-James, James' son takes his place. Remus? Er...he's not even mentioned as decent competition.

Assertion 6: James and Sirius are a unified force of chaos. Remus and Sirius are sort of there.

Supporting evidence: Pensieve Scene. James and Sirius are beautiful together. They move like one, they are seen as one, they are described as inseperable. They are two individuals, interacting with each other and the world around them and just sort of becoming one being. Remus and Sirius make a few cold remarks to each other. "I wish it was the full moon" "You would". They even make a few warm remarks to each other, late book 5. They never have the same sort of feel to them as James and Sirius. They are two people, who sometimes interact. They gave a joint Xmas present, once. And ah, once, Remus looked at Sirius. But "Love does not consist of gazing at each other, but looking outward in the same direction.", afterall.

Assertion 7: James and Sirius respect each other.

Supporting evidence: James stops the whole snitch thing, when Sirius got annoyed with Peter. He doesn't stop for Lily-Evans. Sirius tries to feed Sev to Remus, and laughs about it later in front of Remus. Remus orders Sirius to "Sit down", when Sirius is having an adult conversation with Molly. He butts into Sirius' personal business. He does nothing to help Sirius' depression. What Sirius really wants? Is James. Sniffie.

以上这些也是我对这一CP的部分看法,暂时先说到这里,日后慢慢补。


评论

© 清蓝 | Powered by LOFTER